top of page
pexels-charles-parker-5847373.jpg

Why Rational People Sustain Irrational Organisational Patterns

7 hours ago
7 min read


How individually sensible decisions can combine to produce outcomes that no one in the institution would consciously choose.



An advisor avoids challenging a senior colleague because maintaining the relationship is important. An executive approves an exception because refusing it would delay a client matter. A department protects its resources because its own performance depends on retaining control. A founder intervenes in a decision because resolving it personally is faster than allowing a less experienced colleague to work through the problem.


Each action has a reasonable explanation. The advisor protects an important relationship, the executive prioritises the client, the department safeguards its responsibilities and the founder prevents unnecessary delay. Yet when these behaviours become recurring features of the organisation, their combined effect can be considerably less rational than the decisions that produced them.


The institution may gradually develop a culture of avoidance, inconsistent standards, departmental protection and executive dependency, despite being populated by capable people who have no intention of creating those conditions. Organisational dysfunction does not always emerge from irrational individuals. It can emerge from the interaction of individually rational decisions.


Understanding this distinction is important for private wealth management firms because many of the patterns that constrain their development are not established through formal policy or deliberate leadership instruction. They emerge through repeated responses to the pressures, incentives and expectations of everyday organisational life.





The difference between individual and institutional rationality



People make decisions from the position they occupy, using the information available to them and considering the consequences they are personally responsible for managing. An advisor evaluates a situation through the client relationship, an executive through their operational responsibilities and a department through the objectives against which its performance is assessed.


Within those boundaries, a decision can be entirely sensible. The difficulty is that the interests of an individual role do not always align with the interests of the institution as a whole. An action that protects one relationship can weaken consistency across the firm; a decision that improves departmental performance can create additional work elsewhere; and an exception that resolves an immediate issue can establish an expectation that becomes difficult to manage in future.


This is a distinction between local and institutional outcomes. Local rationality concerns whether an action makes sense within the immediate circumstances of the person making it. Institutional rationality concerns whether the accumulated consequences of those actions support the organisation's wider objectives and long-term interests.


The two are not automatically aligned. In fact, an institution can become increasingly inefficient precisely because people are responding intelligently to the conditions in which they operate. If those conditions reward short-term convenience, discourage challenge or make personal accountability disproportionately costly, employees will often adapt their behaviour accordingly.


The resulting pattern may appear irrational when viewed from the perspective of the institution, while remaining perfectly understandable from the perspective of the individuals sustaining it.





How reasonable decisions become organisational patterns



The transition from individual behaviour to institutional behaviour rarely requires a formal agreement. It often begins with a practical response that produces an immediate benefit.

Consider a firm in which advisors regularly seek senior approval before handling unusual client situations. Initially, this may be an appropriate safeguard. Senior executives possess greater experience, understand the firm's standards and can help protect important relationships. However, if the firm repeatedly rewards escalation with quick resolutions while leaving independent judgement less supported, employees learn that referring decisions upwards is the safer course of action.


Over time, the behaviour becomes normal. Executives become accustomed to intervening, advisors become less confident in their own authority, and the organisation begins to treat senior involvement as an ordinary requirement rather than an occasional necessity. What began as a sensible response to uncertainty becomes a recurring dependency.


Organisational research helps explain why these patterns persist. Nava Ashraf and Oriana Bandiera's review of social incentives in organisations, published in the Annual Review of Economics in 2018, demonstrates that colleagues, managers and other social relationships influence individual effort and behaviour. These social incentives can strengthen productivity, but they can also undermine it or interfere with financial incentives. People do not respond only to formal rewards; they also respond to the expectations and reactions of those around them.


This matters because organisational behaviour is reinforced through experience. Employees observe which actions receive approval, which decisions attract criticism, where exceptions are tolerated and what happens when someone challenges an established way of working. These observations gradually establish expectations that can become more influential than the firm's stated principles.


A firm may formally encourage initiative while informally rewarding caution. It may promote collaboration while measuring performance in ways that encourage departmental competition. It may value consistent client experiences while allowing influential individuals to establish their own standards. In each case, the organisation communicates two different sets of expectations: what it says it values and what its everyday conditions actually reward.





Why patterns survive even when people recognise the problem



One of the more difficult aspects of organisational behaviour is that recognising a problem does not necessarily give individuals a compelling reason to change it. Existing patterns often provide a degree of predictability, protection or convenience, even when their collective consequences are undesirable.


An executive who repeatedly resolves problems personally may recognise that the practice creates dependency. Yet intervening remains faster, carries less immediate risk and avoids the possibility of an inexperienced colleague making a mistake. An advisor who avoids challenging an established practice may recognise its limitations, but speaking up could damage an important working relationship or create uncertainty about their standing within the firm.


The decision to preserve the existing behaviour is therefore not necessarily an endorsement of the wider pattern. It can simply reflect the fact that changing it carries immediate personal costs, while the benefits of change are distributed across the institution and may take considerably longer to materialise.


Research into organisational routines supports this explanation. Peter Kesting's 2023 paper, (Ex)Change of Routines: An Action-Based Microfoundation, examines how repeated actions become embedded in organisational routines. It highlights an important distinction: routines can adapt incrementally, but they can also become resistant to more fundamental change. Established ways of working acquire their own momentum because individuals develop knowledge and familiarity through repetition.


The implication is that organisational patterns do not require continuous conscious endorsement to survive. Once embedded in everyday activity, they can be reproduced by people who have never explicitly chosen them, and who may not even recognise the extent to which their own behaviour contributes to their persistence.





The problem with treating symptoms as isolated behaviours



When leadership identifies an organisational problem, the natural response is often to address the visible behaviour. If advisors escalate too many decisions, management may introduce delegation guidelines. If departments fail to collaborate, leadership may establish additional meetings. If employees avoid raising concerns, the firm may encourage more open communication.


These responses can be useful, but they are incomplete when they address behaviour without examining the conditions producing it. A delegation policy will have limited influence if employees still believe that independent decisions expose them to disproportionate criticism. Additional meetings will not necessarily improve collaboration if departments remain rewarded for protecting their own results. Encouraging openness will achieve little if previous challenges have been met with negative consequences.


A more accurate understanding begins with the relationship between behaviour and its surrounding conditions. What does the individual gain by acting this way? What risk are they avoiding? Which expectations are they responding to? What happens when someone behaves differently? And how does the organisation reinforce the pattern through its decisions, incentives and informal responses?


These questions shift attention away from assigning responsibility to particular individuals and towards understanding the mechanisms through which behaviour becomes established. They also reveal why an organisation can experience the same problems across different employees and successive leadership teams: the individuals change, but the conditions shaping their behaviour remain largely intact.





The institution must be understood before its behaviour can change



For private wealth management firms, the consequences extend into areas that directly influence institutional performance. Advisor discretion, client relationship management, leadership authority, internal collaboration and the consistency of service all depend, to some degree, on how people interpret expectations and respond to their working environment.


A firm may have experienced advisors, capable executives and clearly documented policies, yet still produce inconsistent outcomes because the behaviours connecting those capabilities are not aligned. The issue is not necessarily a lack of competence. It may be that the organisation has developed conditions under which otherwise capable people repeatedly make decisions that undermine collective effectiveness.


This is why organisational behaviour cannot be understood solely through formal structures, employee assessments or leadership perceptions. The institution must be examined as it actually operates: the decisions people make, the expectations they follow, the informal rules they observe and the consequences that reinforce their actions.


The distinction also has implications for institutional development. Changing an established pattern without understanding its underlying causes can simply replace one problem with another. Restricting discretion, for example, may reduce inconsistency while weakening the initiative required for effective client relationships. Increasing accountability may improve oversight while encouraging further risk avoidance if employees do not have the authority and confidence to act.


The objective is not to assume that every established behaviour is harmful or that every individual response should be standardised. It is to understand which patterns support the institution's long-term interests, which create unintended constraints and why those patterns continue to exist.





The organisation produces more than its people intend



An institution is not simply the sum of the intentions, capabilities and decisions of its employees. It is also the product of the relationships between them, the conditions in which they operate and the behaviours that become established through repeated interaction.


This explains why capable people can sustain organisational patterns that no individual would deliberately design. Each person responds to their immediate circumstances, while the institution absorbs the cumulative consequences of those responses. Over time, the resulting behaviour can become self-reinforcing, even when it conflicts with the firm's stated ambitions.


For leadership, the important question is therefore not simply whether employees are making good decisions. It is whether the conditions surrounding those decisions consistently produce outcomes that serve the institution.


An organisation's behaviour is revealed not only by what its people intend to do, but by what they repeatedly find themselves doing — and by the conditions that make those actions seem reasonable.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page